[Vm-dev] ECOOP'20 Berlin - Call for Papers
lists at fniephaus.com
Fri Nov 29 11:06:49 UTC 2019
The 34th Edition of ECOOP
Call for Papers
13th-17th July 2020
ECOOP is a conference about programming. Originally its primary focus
was on object orientation, but now it looks at a much broader range of
programming topics. Areas of interest include, at least, the design,
implementation, optimization, analysis, and theory of programs,
programming languages, and programming environments. It solicits both
innovative and creative solutions to real problems as well as
evaluations of existing solutions—evaluations that provide new
insights. It also encourages the submission of reproduction studies.
ECOOP 2020 solicits high-quality submissions describing original,
The program committee will evaluate the technical contribution of each
submission as well as its general relevance and accessibility to the
ECOOP audience according to the following criteria:
- Originality. Papers must present new ideas and place them
appropriately within the context established by previous research in
- Significance. The results in the paper must have the potential to
add significantly to the state of the art or practice.
- Evidence. The paper must present evidence supporting its claims.
Examples of evidence include implemented systems, experimental
results, statistical analyses, case studies, formalizations, and
- Clarity. The paper must present its contributions and results
On submission, authors will be asked to identify their paper with one
of the following categories:
- Research Paper. This is the most traditional category and solicits
high quality research papers that demonstrate advances in the field.
(As an alternative to being published in the conference proceedings,
authors may wish to submit research papers to be considered for
publication in ACM TOPLAS or Science of Computer Programming.)
- Tool Insights Paper. These submissions focus on the practical
details of the design and implementation of PL tools—details that
are often omitted from regular research papers, despite being
fascinating and worthy of communication. A strong Tool Insights
Paper should communicate engineering experience and insights that
are likely to be useful to other members of the PL community, who
may face similar problems in future. Examples of issues that Tool
Insights Papers might focus on include, but are not limited to:
performance, reliability, portability, inter-tool integration,
infrastructure re-use, evaluation issues, theory/practice gaps,
precision/efficiency, and soundness/efficiency trade-offs.
- Reproduction Study. A Reproduction Study is an empirical evaluation.
It reconstructs an already published experiment but in a different
context (for example, using a different virtual machine or platform,
or in a different class of applications) in order to validate or
refute important results of earlier work. A good Reproduction Study
includes thorough empirical evaluation as well as a detailed
comparison with the previous results, providing reasons for possible
disagreements. (A thoroughly-conducted Reproduction Study that
perfectly replicates an existing experiment and reaches the same
conclusions will be regarded as significant, so long as said
experiment is significant enough to be worthy of reproduction.)
- Experience Report. Such reports focus on noteworthy applications of
known PL techniques, tools, and ideas in interesting domains and by
other communities. Examples include, but are not limited to,
applications of PL techniques in industry, open source, education,
and other academic disciplines. We welcome reports on successful
applications of PL ideas and reports that shed light on limitations
and problems that may provide inspiration for future research.
- Pearl. This category solicits articles that explain a known idea in
a new and elegant way, to the benefit of the PL community. A Pearl
may well be shorter than a regular research paper, but there is no
hard requirement on this.
- Brave New Idea. The Brave New Idea category solicits forward-looking
articles on ideas in the field of PL that may take some time to
substantiate, but for which early communication to the community is
likely to be of benefit. For this category we welcome papers that
are particularly conceptually novel or unconventional and that as a
result may be harder to back up by traditional evaluation methods. A
Brave New Idea paper may well be shorter than a regular research
paper, but there is no requirement for it to be so.
Only papers that have not been published and are not under review for
publication elsewhere may be submitted. Double submissions will be
rejected without review. If major parts of an ECOOP submission have
appeared elsewhere in any form, authors are required to notify the
ECOOP program chair and explain the overlap and relationship. Authors
are also required to inform the program chair about closely related
work submitted to another conference while the ECOOP submission is
Papers must be no longer than 25 pages, excluding references. See
below for information about appendices. Authors will not be penalized
for papers that are shorter than the page limit.
Submissions will be carried out electronically via the conference
ECOOP Proceedings are published by Dagstuhl LIPIcs. Papers must be
written in English and follow the Dagstuhl LIPIcs LaTeX-style
template . Authors retain ownership of their content.
Note: Submitted papers do not need to include the ACM classification
or keywords. Also, please DO NOT put your name in either the \author
or \Copyright macro, in order to maintain anonymity for double-blind
reviewing (see below).
ECOOP will use light double-blind reviewing: authors’ identities are
withheld until a reviewer submits his or her review (as usual, reviews
are anonymous). To facilitate this, submitted papers must adhere to
- Author names and institutions must be omitted.
- References to authors’ own other work should be in the third person
(for example, not “We build on our previous work…” but rather “We
build on the work of…”).
When in doubt, contact the Program Chair.
Clearly marked additional appendices containing analyses, statistics,
supporting proofs, etc. of possible value to reviewers but not
published in the final publication, may be included beyond the page
limit. The submission system provides an option to submit
supplementary material; for example, a technical report including
proofs, or web pages and repositories that cannot easily be
anonymized. This supplementary material will be made available to
reviewers after the initial reviews have been completed, when author
names are revealed.
Reviewers are under no obligation to examine such appendices and
supplementary material. Therefore, the paper must be a stand-alone
document - the appendices and supplementary material are a way of
providing useful information that cannot fit in the page limit; they
are not a means to extend the page limit.
Authors of papers that have been submitted but not accepted by
previous conferences may optionally submit a Note to Reviewers. The
Note to Reviewers should provide the following information:
- the identity of the previous venue(s) (for example, ESOP 2020,
‹Programming› 2020, POPL 2020, OOPSLA 2019)
- a list the major issues identified by the reviews at those venues
- a description of the changes made to the paper in response to those
These notes will be made available to reviewers after their initial
reviews have been completed and author names have been revealed.
Authors will be given a three-day period to read and respond to the
reviews of their papers before the program committee meeting.
Responses have no formal length limit, but concision is likely to be
To reward the creation of artifacts and support replication of
experiments, authors of accepted research papers may submit artifacts
(such as tools, data, models, or videos) to be evaluated by an
Artifact Evaluation Committee. Artifacts that pass muster will be
- Paper submission: 10 January 2020 (Fri)
- Author response: 16–18 March 2020 (Mon-Wed)
- Author notification: 8 April 2020 (Wed)
We have Journal First arrangements with ACM Transactions on
Programming Languages and Systems and Elsevier Science of Computer
Common to both routes
Only new research papers are eligible for the Journal First routes to
ECOOP 2020. That is, it is not acceptable to submit an extension of a
previous conference paper, even if the associated journal solicits
extended papers via its standard submission route.
Authors of all accepted Journal First papers will be invited to submit
a short abstract for their paper to appear in the ECOOP 2020
Journal First papers will be included along with research papers
submitted directly to the conference when a Distinguished Paper is
Science of Computer Programming route
See this dedicated web page  for full details of how to submit to
the ECOOP 2020 Science of Computer Programming (SCP) special issue.
Submission deadline: December 2, 2019 (Mon)
ACM Transactions on Programming Languages and Systems route
See this announcement  for details of the TOPLAS scheme whereby
papers submitted to TOPLAS can be presented at selected conferences.
Authors interested in this route should submit their paper to TOPLAS
via its usual submission system and mark it as an ECOOP 2020
submission. The ECOOP Program Chair will then be informed of this
submission and will have some input into the review process.
Submission deadline: October 10, 2019 (Thu)
For additional information, please contact the ECOOP Program Chair,
Robert Hirschfeld .
More information about the Vm-dev