Hi all,

After stumbling around a bit on the icon8.com web site, it looks like we
will be fine to use their icons freely, in any form obtained from their web
site. We just are not allowed to edit them except for the most basic
operations.
https://icons8.com/license
https://icons8.com/pricing (scroll down, read the Free pane on the left)
https://community.icons8.com/t/recolor-an-icon/1424
https://icons8.com/articles/we-contributed-icon-to-imageoptim/
It might be nice to tell them that we use some of their icons:
http://disq.us/p/1p1l0dn

However, not all content in Squeak is actually under the proclaimed MIT
license. This does not only apply to these icons, but also to the already
included fonts.
https://www.fontsquirrel.com/license/Bitstream-Vera-Sans
We have to reproduce their copyright notice.

Should Squeak's license statement therefore not include a list of the
included parts and their licenses? Currently it only lists the MIT license
and the Apache License under Help > License Information and on the website:
https://squeak.org/license/

It would be more appropriate to include the attribution notice in a more
visible place than the methods with the bytes in them. Most users will not
look there. Somewhere in the About window, or a small notice on the welcome
screen would be more suitable.

If you agree that this should be done, I suggest to do it rather before the
release than after. Maybe not looking through the complete image, but at
least catalogue the known parts: icons and fonts.

Kind regards,
Jakob


Am Fr., 14. Feb. 2020 um 13:19 Uhr schrieb Thiede, Christoph <
Christoph.Thiede at student.hpi.uni-potsdam.de>:

> Their german version (which also lists the icons) mentions the license:
> https://icons8.de/license ^^
>
> <http://www.hpi.de/>
> ------------------------------
> *Von:* Squeak-dev <squeak-dev-bounces at lists.squeakfoundation.org> im
> Auftrag von Jakob Reschke <forums.jakob at resfarm.de>
> *Gesendet:* Freitag, 14. Februar 2020 12:46:01
> *An:* The general-purpose Squeak developers list
> *Betreff:* Re: [squeak-dev] The Inbox: Tools-ct.940.mcz
>
> Here are further terms, but no mention of the Creative Commons license.
>
> https://icons8.com/license
>
> These don't look like the usual legalese. Maybe the site has some official
> terms buried somewhere.
>
>
> Thiede, Christoph <Christoph.Thiede at student.hpi.uni-potsdam.de> schrieb
> am Fr., 14. Feb. 2020, 09:34:
>
>> Good question ...
>>
>>
>>    1. See #checkmark (added by Marcel), it uses the same license and
>>    cite.
>>    2. The original picture is from here:
>>    https://img.icons8.com/metro/26/000000/settings.png (Unfortunately,
>>    you cannot link to the containing page directly). But if you search for any
>>    icon on the page, you will be offered to "edit it in lunancy", probably to
>>    change the color. So don't they want this?
>>    3. There is no author specified, so I assume the "author" is "icons8".
>>
>> <http://www.hpi.de/>
>>
>> However, if there is someone able to design a better icon, he or she is
>> welcome to do so :-)
>> ------------------------------
>> *Von:* Squeak-dev <squeak-dev-bounces at lists.squeakfoundation.org> im
>> Auftrag von Jakob Reschke <forums.jakob at resfarm.de>
>> *Gesendet:* Freitag, 14. Februar 2020 08:34:15
>> *An:* squeak-dev at lists.squeakfoundation.org
>> *Betreff:* Re: [squeak-dev] The Inbox: Tools-ct.940.mcz
>>
>> Does this not violate the license of the icon? It says attribution and no
>> derivatives, yet I see no name of the creator and the comment states
>> "modified".
>>
>> Am Do., 13. Feb. 2020 um 01:24 Uhr schrieb <commits at source.squeak.org>:
>>
>>> Christoph Thiede uploaded a new version of Tools to project The Inbox:
>>> http://source.squeak.org/inbox/Tools-ct.940.mcz
>>>
>>> ==================== Summary ====================
>>>
>>> Name: Tools-ct.940
>>> Author: ct
>>> Time: 13 February 2020, 1:23:45.731118 am
>>> UUID: 7ce769dd-d29e-4b4e-a10a-7b79b2e19fc1
>>> Ancestors: Tools-topa.931
>>>
>>> Proposal: tool icon for Model
>>>
>>> =============== Diff against Tools-topa.931 ===============
>>>
>>> Item was added:
>>> + ----- Method: Model class>>toolIcon (in category '*Tools-icons') -----
>>> + toolIcon
>>> +
>>> +       ^ #gear!
>>>
>>> Item was added:
>>> + ----- Method: ToolIcons class>>gear (in category 'private') -----
>>> + gear
>>> +       "© 2020 Icon8. Modified.
>>> +       Website: https://icons8.com
>>> +       License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/3.0/"
>>> +
>>> +       ^ Form fromBinaryStream: (Base64MimeConverter mimeDecodeToBytes:
>>> 'iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAEAAAABACAYAAACqaXHeAAAHxklEQVR4XuWbWU8UQRCA/YGQiAgi4oEnoOCBYIIaUVBQJAGEhBAF9Ul9UDyCigdRRAUTA9EID4pGUEANhxeHR5mvkybtbO/sLDgD7nYyYZntrq6qrrt6l8T/CGDMzMzI9+/frc/Pnz8l5hlw8+ZNKS8vl+PHj88+x44dk4qKCnny5EnsM+DEiROyevVqycrKmn22bNki69atkzNnzsQ+A6qrqxXB+fn5smvXLvXwmXe1tbWxzYCxsTEpKyuTnJycWeL1k52dLZWVlYKNiFkGvHz5Uvbv3y/btm0LYcDWrVvl0KFDMjg4+H8w4Pfv3zI0NBQVsp2dnUrct2/fHsKA3NxcKSwslKdPn0YFExx+/foVPNPu3LkjK1askMbGRs+bt7S0KFHfsWNHCAN4h2rcuHHDMzyMJji0trYGy4B79+7JsmXLFNKZmZmyZ88eeffuXUQkLl++LJs2bQohXj98x5xIcEZGRmTv3r1qb3BITk4WDiQQ4u/evSsJCQmzVpy/uLKVK1dKe3t7CBKI58DAgNTX1ytk8/LywjKA75jT0NAg79+/t4p2V1eXZGRkyObNm//CAZzAzVfib926pU7edGGmCHMSuDms/ZcvXxRCiPXSpUtl48aNrsSbTGBuUlKSgvno0SP59u2bfP78WU6ePKn2t9kQcGJ/39RhdHRUVq1aZd3cRGLt2rVKPPft2ydpaWnKuNkY5uXBW6SkpMjhw4flyJEjan83WOCWnp4u4OoLE5qbmxWBbkiDIIjj1sz3O3fuVMxAXTZs2KAiP06ah8+8IxhiDnPNtUgR8CIxEtzA0Vc1KC0tVUh7PUWIwfJjsHbv3i2EwufOnZOLFy/K1atX1cPn8+fPq0iQOcxljZMRbg84I
>>>
>>>  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
>>>  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'
>>> readStream)!
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.squeakfoundation.org/pipermail/squeak-dev/attachments/20200214/84b07ce2/attachment-0001.html>