[squeak-dev] Date today versus DateAndTime today
ron at usmedrec.com
Thu Dec 9 17:06:38 UTC 2021
On Thu, Dec 9, 2021 at 4:40 AM Marcel Taeumel <marcel.taeumel at hpi.de> wrote:
> Hi Bernhard --
> Date is a Timespan while DateAndTime is not. I think we should drop the
> timezone offset when converting a DateAndTime to a Date. Yet, the class
> comment of Date reads, that there are rare cases where one would need such
> an offset. Not sure.
In my opinion, The result of the comparison should only consider the result
of the date with the offset applied. While it is true that the
original date + offset might result in a different date the result should
still be true if the resulting dates are the same. One is the result of
the date plus the offset the other is a date but they are both Functionally
equal. The results currently are converting both dates to UTC before the
self asUTC hasEqualTicks: aDateAndTimeOrTimeStamp asUTC
That to me is the error. If you wanted to make that comparison you would
do asUTC yourself to remove timezone information.
I can not fathom a reason that DateAndTime today asDate = Date today. is
better by returning false. Anyone worried about timezones in this instance
would use UTC or local conversions first before doing the comparison.
All the best,
> In any case, "DateAndTime today" and "Date today" have different use
> cases. If you need an accurate timestamp, use DateAndTime. If you write an
> application that needs to handle time of some sorts (including calendars
> and games), use Date, Month, Week, Year.
> Looking at the "STON" project, I find it strange that there are extensions
> on both DateAndTime and Date, given that this is primarily used in version
> control. You should only use DateAndTime in such scenarios.
> Am 08.12.2021 23:22:03 schrieb Bernhard Pieber <bernhard at pieber.com>:
> Hi everyone,
> I am quite puzzled that the following answers false:
> DateAndTime today asDate = Date today.
> The reason seems to be the localOffsetSeconds. While DateAndTime today
> asDate has a local timezone, Date today has not. Shouldn’t this be
> The following answers false as well:
> Date today start = DateAndTime today
> I assume it is for the same reason.
> I suppose this is a feature, not a bug, but what is the reason for this
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Squeak-dev