[etoys-dev] Translation support

[Ricardo Moran]

Thank you for the correction of the code. I was missing the most important
translations!

Correct me if I'm wrong please, you are proposing:
1) to change the TextDomainManager to link the domain with the package
instead of the class category,
2) to store this information in the method properties,
3) and to make #translated aware of all this changes.

Right?

Richo

On Sat, May 1, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Bert Freudenberg <bert at freudenbergs.de>wrote:

> I think we do want to do something along those lines, yes.
>
> Your expression misses some phrases, in particular the Etoys tile
> inscriptions:
>
>  "Count tile phrases"
> domains := Dictionary new.
> GetTextExporter2 new appendVocabularies: domains.
>  phrases := Set new.
> domains do: [:translations | phrases addAll: translations keys].
> phrases size
>  "==> 748 phrases"
>
> These tile phrases should be a separate pot IMHO, because those are the
> most important ones to translate.
>
> Other than that, splitting by category seems reasonable. And since
> development is organized by packages now, maybe we should just have one po
> file per top-level category? Even if there is only 1 phrase in it?
>
> I'm sure Korakurider has thought about that. Let's hear him :)
>
> Here's my code to count phrases per package:
>
> ==============
>  "Count non-tile phrases per category"
> domains := Dictionary new.
> GetTextExporter2 new
>  appendStringReceivers: #translated into: domains;
> appendStringReceivers: #translatedNoop into: domains.
> phrases := Dictionary new.
>  domains  do: [:translations |
> translations keysAndValuesDo: [:phrase :mrefs |
> mrefs do: [:mref |
>  category := (SystemOrganization categoryOfElement:  mref classSymbol)
> copyUpTo: $-.
> (phrases at: category ifAbsentPut: [Set new])
>  add: phrase]]].
> categories := Bag new.
> phrases keysAndValuesDo: [:cat :strings |
>  categories add: cat withOccurrences: strings size].
> categories sortedCounts
> ==============
>
> There are 4251 non-tile phrases (sum of the below). Adding the 748 tile
> phrases and subtracting some duplicates this is in the ballpark of the 4412
> phrases on pootle.
>
> 1427 Morphic
> 751 MorphicExtras
> 506 Etoys
> 262 System
> 252 Connectors
> 201 Tools
> 182 Sound
> 70 Movies
> 67 ST80
> 65 Protocols
> 62 Multilingual
> 60 Nebraska
> 55 Sugar
> 48 VideoForSqueak
> 38 WS
> 30 Graphics
> 28 Network
> 25 GStreamer
> 24 Kernel
> 20 Flash
> 19 Files
> 13 Compression
> 11 Collections
> 10 FSM
> 8 Balloon
> 7 BroomMorphs
> 5 Monticello
> 2 SMLoader
> 1 DAVServerDirectory
> 1 UserObjects
> 1 TrueType
>
> If we wanted to split Morphic further, these would be the numbers (but I
> don't think we should):
>
> 569 Morphic-Kernel
> 251 Morphic-Worlds
> 161 Morphic-Mentoring
> 135 Morphic-Basic
> 100 Morphic-Games
> 67 Morphic-Widgets
> 48 Morphic-Experimental
> 47 Morphic-Windows
> 19 Morphic-Demo
> 18 Morphic-Scripting Tiles
> 13 Morphic-Components
> 13 Morphic-Support
> 12 Morphic-Text Support
> 8 Morphic-TrueType
> 7 Morphic-Menus
> 7 Morphic-Pluggable Widgets
> 6 Morphic-Books
> 5 Morphic-PDA
> 1 Morphic-PartsBin
>
> There is a slight problem with extension methods (methods defined in
> *categories), #translated currently would look for those in the wrong
> package:
>
> ==============
>  "Count non-tile phrases that are in extension methods"
> domains := Dictionary new.
> GetTextExporter2 new
>  appendStringReceivers: #translated into: domains;
> appendStringReceivers: #translatedNoop into: domains.
> extensionMethods := Set new.
>  MCWorkingCopy allManagers do: [:wc |
> extensionMethods addAll: wc packageInfo extensionMethods].
> phrases := Dictionary new.
>  domains  do: [:translations |
> translations keysAndValuesDo: [:phrase :mrefs |
> mrefs do: [:mref |
>  (extensionMethods includes: mref) ifTrue: [
> category := (mref category copyUpTo: $-) asLowercase.
> (phrases at: category ifAbsentPut: [Set new])
>  add: phrase]]]].
> categories := Bag new.
> phrases keysAndValuesDo: [:cat :strings |
>  categories add: cat withOccurrences: strings size].
> categories sortedCounts
> ==============
>
> 199 *etoys
> 83 *morphicextras
> 18 *connectors
> 8 *morphic
> 5 *sound
> 1 *pango
>
> We need to make #translated deal with this. I can think of a simple but
> inefficient way to do it - maybe it wouldn't hurt that much?
>
> - Bert -
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> etoys-dev mailing list
> etoys-dev at squeakland.org
> http://lists.squeakland.org/mailman/listinfo/etoys-dev
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.squeakland.org/pipermail/etoys-dev/attachments/20100504/5d9341d4/attachment.html