[SoC] Voting policy

Giovanni Corriga giovanni at corriga.net
Wed Apr 9 23:34:00 UTC 2008


Matthew Fulmer ha scritto:
> -1 .. +7 is what I used (9 points of resolution). I made use of
> each score (except for +7) for at least one application.
> 
> So, in summary, if your votes have 9 points of resolution, they
> are on par with mine, no matter how you decide to score each
> project
> 

Hi Matthew,

your guidelines can be acceptable (even though I have some reservations 
about giving a -1 to PhD). The important thing that I'd like for 
everyone to agree on is the maximum value to use. I propose not to give 
a score greater than +6 to any proposal, even if you don't agree to this 
guidelines. In case someone exceeds this limit, as the admin I'll add 
negative scores in order to "scale down" that score.

	Giovanni


More information about the SoC mailing list