Aaron J Reichow reic0024@d.umn.edu wrote about BioSqueaking: One of my beefs with the latest 'bioinformatics' craze is that it seems that biology and bioinformatics = genetics, leaving out all the other subfields of biology. I use Squeak to analyze and visualize ecological data, and that is within the realm of bioinformatics.
I wouldn't mind hearing about that. It sounds an interesting application of Squeak, and I know of someone who might be interested in using it.
Consequently, all the Bio* libraries only deal with this rapidly growing, but exclusive part of biology. I think that part of the reason is that studying genes and proteins leads to huge databases full of very long sequences; algorithms for processing these things form a coherent subdiscipline of computer science. (Which I am beating my brains out trying to get my head around. Oodles of books that tell you how to run program Foo, papers scattered all over the library that are original sources, very very few books that clearly explain how the darned things *work*.)
Ecological modelling and analysis is also a well-studied area. It is about biology, and it's informatics, but it has different problems and methods.
What do we, those who are/will be working on biosqueak, want the extent of BioSqueak to be?
Squeak's Squeak. I can't imagine anything interesting being turned away. I can't imagine it working in the next release but one either, but that's another story.
Or do we want to have class libraries that assist with genomics (with similar capabilities as the other packages available) as well as other fields of biology like phylogeny, ecology, or others? Phylogeny is commonly included in bioinformatics, * because many biologists are interested in genes and proteins primarily as a way of getting characters to base phylogenies on, and * because having a phylogeny can help "focus" some alignment algorithms so that people who are interested in the genes want phylogenies so they can get the genes faster. No two ways about it, phylogeny belongs in.
squeak-dev@lists.squeakfoundation.org