A friend is trying to get this to work – is it supposed to work?
"SimpleMIDIPort primPortCount" evaluates to 0, even when I have a MIDI
controller plugged in. And "SimpleMIDIPort openDefault" gives me a primitive failed error.
Vanessa
Hi
On 21. Mar 2024, at 17:37, Vanessa Freudenberg vanessa@codefrau.net wrote:
A friend is trying to get this to work – is it supposed to work?
"SimpleMIDIPort primPortCount" evaluates to 0, even when I have a MIDI controller plugged in.
And "SimpleMIDIPort openDefault" gives me a primitive failed error.
It could™ work, yet, I noticed that the API used is outdated since 10 years, so there's that. So, it might depend on the macOS used. I wanted to fix that since forever
Best regards -Tobias
Of course I couldn't let this sit there. As of just now, SqueakJS supports actual MIDI 🥳 At least in Chrome:
You can run an image, drop in a MIDI file, and play it.
I don't have a hardware synth so I tested MIDI output via GarageBand. The Steinway Grand sounds great playing the Moonlight sonata. Here's a video with sound:
https://freudenbergs.de/vanessa/squeakjs/SqueakJS-MIDI.mp4
Should work in pretty much any Squeak version (I tried in 6.2, too).
I tested MIDI input using the MidiKeys app since I don't have a real keyboard. It's implemented and the data coming into the image looks right, but the MidiSynth class's playback does not sound quite right.
Also, it's not entirely clear what epoch/units the midi clock is supposed to be in – possibly because Squeak changed millisecondClockValue to not start at 0 anymore, whereas older images (or at least the MIDI code in it) expects that.
If anyone wants to hack it, my WebMIDI plugin code is in:
https://github.com/codefrau/SqueakJS/blob/main/plugins/MIDIPlugin.js
Have fun 💜 Vanessa
On Thu, Mar 21, 2024 at 9:44 AM Tobias Pape via Vm-dev < vm-dev@lists.squeakfoundation.org> wrote:
Hi
On 21. Mar 2024, at 17:37, Vanessa Freudenberg vanessa@codefrau.net
wrote:
A friend is trying to get this to work – is it supposed to work?
"SimpleMIDIPort primPortCount" evaluates to 0, even when I have a MIDI
controller plugged in.
And "SimpleMIDIPort openDefault" gives me a primitive failed error.
It could™ work, yet, I noticed that the API used is outdated since 10 years, so there's that. So, it might depend on the macOS used. I wanted to fix that since forever
Best regards -Tobias
This is very exciting! Thank you!
On 2024-03-25 03:19, Vanessa Freudenberg wrote:
Of course I couldn't let this sit there. As of just now, SqueakJS supports actual MIDI 🥳 At least in Chrome:
You can run an image, drop in a MIDI file, and play it.
I don't have a hardware synth so I tested MIDI output via GarageBand. The Steinway Grand sounds great playing the Moonlight sonata. Here's a video with sound:
https://freudenbergs.de/vanessa/squeakjs/SqueakJS-MIDI.mp4
Should work in pretty much any Squeak version (I tried in 6.2, too).
I tested MIDI input using the MidiKeys app since I don't have a real keyboard. It's implemented and the data coming into the image looks right, but the MidiSynth class's playback does not sound quite right.
Also, it's not entirely clear what epoch/units the midi clock is supposed to be in - possibly because Squeak changed millisecondClockValue to not start at 0 anymore, whereas older images (or at least the MIDI code in it) expects that.
If anyone wants to hack it, my WebMIDI plugin code is in:
https://github.com/codefrau/SqueakJS/blob/main/plugins/MIDIPlugin.js
Have fun 💜 Vanessa
On Thu, Mar 21, 2024 at 9:44 AM Tobias Pape via Vm-dev vm-dev@lists.squeakfoundation.org wrote:
Hi
On 21. Mar 2024, at 17:37, Vanessa Freudenberg vanessa@codefrau.net wrote:
A friend is trying to get this to work - is it supposed to work?
"SimpleMIDIPort primPortCount" evaluates to 0, even when I have a MIDI controller plugged in.
And "SimpleMIDIPort openDefault" gives me a primitive failed error.
It could(tm) work, yet, I noticed that the API used is outdated since 10 years, so there's that. So, it might depend on the macOS used. I wanted to fix that since forever
Best regards -Tobias
https://squeak.js.org/ https://squeak.js.org/
You can run an image, drop in a MIDI file, and play it.
Great!
Stef
vm-dev@lists.squeakfoundation.org
-
Stéphane Rollandin -
Tim Johnson -
Tobias Pape -
Todd Blanchard -
Vanessa Freudenberg