Hi Eliot,
Thanks for the explanation. I started looking into the return bytecode 348, but I could not find something suspicious. So I started logging more and then I saw a dim light:
Error in loading dynamic library /SecurityPlugin: Error: need to see wasm magic number Error in loading dynamic library /SecurityPlugin.so: Error: need to see wasm magic number Error in loading dynamic library /libSecurityPlugin.so: Error: need to see wasm magic number Error in loading dynamic library SecurityPlugin: Error: need to see wasm magic number Error in loading dynamic library SecurityPlugin.so: Error: need to see wasm magic number
It finds libSecurityPlugin.so. But it only works as an external plugin, won't find it as an internal plugin. Weird, but it continues.
sqImageFileClose ftruncate: Invalid argument
Opening the image file seems to work, and this is only a warning. Probably some Emscripten-specific ftruncate is needed.
stateMachinePolicy != UNDEFINED 364
Assertion failed in heartbeat clock. I assume this is fine, as it happens only in the beginning
Smalltalk stack dump: 0xaa2fec WorkingSession class(Behavior)>new 0x172b9f0: a(n) WorkingSession 0xaa300c SessionManager>newSession 0x177d300: a(n) SessionManager 0xaa302c SessionManager>installNewSession 0x177d300: a(n) SessionManager 0xaa3050 SessionManager>launchSnapshot:andQuit: 0x177d300: a(n) SessionManager 0x43276f8 s [] in SessionManager>snapshot:andQuit: 0x43278a0 s [] in FullBlockClosure(BlockClosure)>newProcess
This looks good!
currentBytecode = 464 currentBytecode = 320 currentBytecode = 332 currentBytecode = 401 currentBytecode = 272 currentBytecode = 380 currentBytecode = 332 currentBytecode = 384 (localPrimIndex > 0xFF) && (localPrimIndex < 520) 5814 localPrimIndex = 253
Assertion failed in interpreter. Oddly close to 0xFF...
currentBytecode = 385 localPrimIndex = 256 currentBytecode = 348 Smalltalk stack dump: 0xaa2fc4 MessageNotUnderstood class(Behavior)>new 0x1728360: a(n) MessageNotUnderstood 0xaa2fe8 SmallInteger(Object)>doesNotUnderstand: manager: 0xfffffff1=-8
Bottom of stack missing, assume it is SessionManager>>#newSession
newSession | aWorkingSession | aWorkingSession := WorkingSession new. aWorkingSession manager: self. ^ aWorkingSession
#new seemed to have worked, but not #manager:. Not sure how to interpret the 0xfffffff1=-8, and is SmallInteger always the receiver type in the interpreter stack?
currentBytecode = 332 currentBytecode = 384 (localPrimIndex > 0xFF) && (localPrimIndex < 520) 5814 localPrimIndex = 253
253 again. But where is it coming from?
currentBytecode = 385 localPrimIndex = 256 currentBytecode = 348 Smalltalk stack dump: 0xaa2f98 MessageNotUnderstood class(Behavior)>new 0x1728360: a(n) MessageNotUnderstood 0xaa2fbc SmallInteger(Object)>doesNotUnderstand: message: 0xfffffff1=-8 0xaa2fe8 SmallInteger(Object)>doesNotUnderstand: manager: 0xfffffff1=-8 0xaa300c SessionManager>newSession 0x177d300: a(n) SessionManager 0xaa302c SessionManager>installNewSession 0x177d300: a(n) SessionManager 0xaa3050 SessionManager>launchSnapshot:andQuit: 0x177d300: a(n) SessionManager 0x43276f8 s [] in SessionManager>snapshot:andQuit: 0x43278a0 s [] in FullBlockClosure(BlockClosure)>newProcess
Once it reaches #doesNotUnderstand:, we are in an infinite loop.
currentBytecode = 501 currentBytecode = 339 currentBytecode = 320 currentBytecode = 401 currentBytecode = 272 currentBytecode = 380 currentBytecode = 332 currentBytecode = 384 (localPrimIndex > 0xFF) && (localPrimIndex < 520) 5814 localPrimIndex = 253 currentBytecode = 385 localPrimIndex = 256 currentBytecode = 348 Smalltalk stack dump: 0xaa2f6c MessageNotUnderstood class(Behavior)>new 0x1728360: a(n) MessageNotUnderstood 0xaa2f90 SmallInteger(Object)>doesNotUnderstand: message: 0xfffffff1=-8 0xaa2fbc SmallInteger(Object)>doesNotUnderstand: message: 0xfffffff1=-8 0xaa2fe8 SmallInteger(Object)>doesNotUnderstand: manager: 0xfffffff1=-8 0xaa300c SessionManager>newSession 0x177d300: a(n) SessionManager 0xaa302c SessionManager>installNewSession 0x177d300: a(n) SessionManager 0xaa3050 SessionManager>launchSnapshot:andQuit: 0x177d300: a(n) SessionManager 0x43276f8 s [] in SessionManager>snapshot:andQuit: 0x43278a0 s [] in FullBlockClosure(BlockClosure)>newProcess
My suspicion is a 32bit/64bit type issue. I also saw a few segfaults in the past, but not recently, and not reproducible. Anybody has a clue on what I should look at next?
Cheers, Manuel
On 27 Jun 2022, at 23:31, Eliot Miranda eliot.miranda@gmail.com wrote:
Hi Manuel,
cool beans!
On Mon, Jun 27, 2022 at 3:54 AM Manuel Leuenberger <maenuleu@gmail.com mailto:maenuleu@gmail.com> wrote:
Hi,
Ever since WebAssembly became a thing, I was wondering if this could become a target for VMs. People are already compiling FFMPEG and other complex tools. So I thought I would try as well.
So here I am to report to whom it may concern: OSVM compiles to WebAssembly, starts up (nearly), then looping infinitely Meaning: The VM mmaps the image file, loads plugins (SecurityPlugin made EXTERNAL), starts interpreter loop, but then loops the same bytecode sequence forever
Code lives at https://github.com/maenu/opensmalltalk-vm/tree/Cog/building/minheadless.cmak... https://github.com/maenu/opensmalltalk-vm/tree/Cog/building/minheadless.cmake/x86/pharo.stack.spur.wasm if you want to try it out.
Below is the current Readme, including a short list of issues. Maybe some of you could give me a hint?
Cheers, Manuel
pharo.stack.spur.wasm
Compiles OSVM Stack interpreter to WebAssembly using the Emscripten compiler. Emscripten can be used as a drop-in replacement for gcc/clang and cmake. Based on MinHeadless Linux 32bit sources, as Emscripten provides Linux-like environment (pthreads, nanosleep, dlopen, file system). Check the latest few commits of maenu to see changed files.
https://github.com/maenu/opensmalltalk-vm/tree/Cog/building/minheadless.cmake/x86/pharo.stack.spur.wasm#current-issuesCurrent issues
Most adjustments are just putting EMSCRIPTEN in a macro or script. Should be fine, but should be tested to not interfere with other builds.
Compiles and runs, but seems to be stuck in initial GC and Heartbeat. Those could be related to incorrect get/set64() implementation.
Removed mmap address hint, as it caused errors.
Using argv eval '1 + 3' to do a simple eval does not terminate.
Interpreter repeats these bytecodes forever (what is this?):
Taking these from e.g. src/spur64.stack/interp.c they are
CASE(112) CASE(332) /*76*/ /* pushReceiverBytecode */
332 CASE(208) CASE(209) CASE(210) CASE(211) CASE(212) CASE(213) CASE(214) CASE(215) CASE(216) CASE(217) CASE(218) CASE(219) CASE(220) CASE(221) CASE(222) CASE(223) CASE(384) /*128*/ i.e. send literal selector 0 with 0 args CASE(385) /*129*/ CASE(386) /*130*/ CASE(387) /*131*/ CASE(388) /*132*/ CASE(389) /*133*/ CASE(390) /*134*/ CASE(391) /*135*/ CASE(392) /*136*/ CASE(393) /*137*/ CASE(394) /*138*/ CASE(395) /*139*/ CASE(396) /*140*/ CASE(397) /*141*/ CASE(398) /*142*/ CASE(399) /*143*/ /* sendLiteralSelector0ArgsBytecode */
384
hence send literal selector 1 with 0 args
385
CASE(124) CASE(348) /*92*/ /* returnTopFromMethod */
348
CASE(501) /*245*/ /* longStoreTemporaryVariableBytecode */
501 CASE(136) CASE(339) /*83*/ /* duplicateTopBytecode */ 339 CASE(16) CASE(320) /*64*/ /* pushTemporaryVariableBytecode */ 320
CASE(224) CASE(225) CASE(226) CASE(227) CASE(228) CASE(229) CASE(230) CASE(231) CASE(232) CASE(233) CASE(234) CASE(235) CASE(236) CASE(237) CASE(238) CASE(239) CASE(400) /*144*/ CASE(401) /*145*/ i.e. send literal selector 1 with 1 arg CASE(402) /*146*/ CASE(403) /*147*/ CASE(404) /*148*/ CASE(405) /*149*/ CASE(406) /*150*/ CASE(407) /*151*/ CASE(408) /*152*/ CASE(409) /*153*/ CASE(410) /*154*/ CASE(411) /*155*/ CASE(412) /*156*/ CASE(413) /*157*/ CASE(414) /*158*/ CASE(415) /*159*/ /* sendLiteralSelector1ArgBytecode */
401 CASE(64) CASE(272) /*16*/ /* pushLiteralVariableBytecode */ 272 CASE(204) CASE(380) /*124*/ /* bytecodePrimNew */ i.e. a send of #new from the special selector bytecode 380
If I had to guess what's going wrong I'd guess that the return bytecode 348 isn't correctly implemented.
https://github.com/maenu/opensmalltalk-vm/tree/Cog/building/minheadless.cmake/x86/pharo.stack.spur.wasm#1-install-emscripten1. Install Emscripten
I installed Emscripten SDK https://emscripten.org/docs/getting_started/downloads.html to get an all-in-one package.
https://github.com/maenu/opensmalltalk-vm/tree/Cog/building/minheadless.cmake/x86/pharo.stack.spur.wasm#2-grab-an-image2. Grab an image
Grab a 32bit Smalltalk image and but it in the image folder. I used Pharo 9.
cd building/minheadless.cmake/x86/pharo.stack.spur.wasm mkdir image cd image curl https://get.pharo.org/32/90 https://get.pharo.org/32/90 | bash https://github.com/maenu/opensmalltalk-vm/tree/Cog/building/minheadless.cmake/x86/pharo.stack.spur.wasm#3-build-vm3. Build VM
./mvm_configure_variant debug Debug && make -C debug install
https://github.com/maenu/opensmalltalk-vm/tree/Cog/building/minheadless.cmake/x86/pharo.stack.spur.wasm#4-run-a-web-server4. Run a web server
emrun --port 9090 --serve_root ../../../../ --no_browser .
http://localhost:9090/building/minheadless.cmake/x86/pharo.stack.spur.wasm/d... http://localhost:9090/building/minheadless.cmake/x86/pharo.stack.spur.wasm/debug/dist/squeak.html https://github.com/maenu/opensmalltalk-vm/tree/Cog/building/minheadless.cmake/x86/pharo.stack.spur.wasm#6-inspect-running-vm6. Inspect running VM
The VM is compiled with DWARF debug information, which is understood by the Chrome debugger. So we can step through the C sources of the WebAssembly, pretty nifty.
Inspect WebAssembly (at the bottom) https://webassembly.org/getting-started/developers-guide/ Emscripten doc (Porting) https://emscripten.org/docs/porting/index.html Emscripten settings https://emsettings.surma.technology/
-- _,,,^..^,,,_ best, Eliot